2012 - A Year of Challenges and Opportunities for the Valuation Profession
The year ahead will hold many changes, challenges and opportunities for
both residential and commercial real estate appraisers. We are in the midst of a worldwide economic
meltdown that challenges our personal and professional lives. For appraisers, these economic difficulties are
compounded by regulatory changes that impact the way residential and commercial
appraisers conduct their business. I
think appraisers have soldiered on through the confusion because we are a time-tested
profession. The average age of a
certified appraiser in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts is in the mid-50s.
Appraisal Institute designated members have an average age slightly older.
Experience makes a difference when you need a credible appraisal.
In 2011 the
commercial real estate market started the year with a boom and ended with a
whimper. After a two year slump the
commercial real estate showed some life in the 1st half of 2011 as
the market experienced rising values in top-tier markets for trophy properties. Unfortunately it was a bifurcated market and
secondary and tertiary markets and properties were largely ignored by this
activity. In this type of market no one
pays a premium for uncertainty. And thus
by the end of the year the market slowed with the possible impending collapse
of the Euro and sovereign debt defaults beginning with Greece.
The residential real estate market continued
to limp along throughout the year, suffering the excesses of the housing boom. Too much product and a public suffering from
housing angst don’t make a healthy market.
For housing the money was available but underwriting standards have
become more rigorous. The popular wisdom
that housing is a “no lose” investment has been sorely tested (until the next
boom).
Appraisers will
continue to be challenged by a limited amount of work related to new financing
in 2012. They will also be challenged by
continued fee compression in the short term.
However, one of the most significant challenges will be appraising in a
market that continues to offer limited comparable data. Sale and rental data will be limited in many
market segments and questions will abound with respect to capitalization and
discount rates.
However, looking
toward the positive, opportunities for appraisers will also abound. The troubled real estate inventory is burning
off and new business is again rising. Now
is the time for appraisers to educate themselves as to appraising in these
market conditions, and to spend time marketing and diversifying their client
base.
Appraisers should
also consider the fact that there will be a flight to quality over the next
year. Regulators, bankers and borrowers
will be seeking quality appraisals by experienced appraisers who know how to
appraise in a slow market with limited comparable data. They will be looking for appraisers with
designations that show their commitment to the profession and that indicate
they are well educated and have completed continuing education
requirements. The MAI and SRA
designations are the most recognized and respected professional designations in
the industry. Now, more than ever,
appraisers should consider membership in the Appraisal Institute. Existing members are urged to become involved
and work to make the organization even stronger.
Rest assured, the
Appraisal Institute is working hard for its members in these challenging and
uncertain times. We offer new courses
reflecting high interest subjects. We
also offer seminars on a regular basis that cover the current economic
climate. The Appraisal Institute’s
national office continues to lobby on Capitol Hill for legislators to recognize
the need for quality appraisal and valuation services. The Appraisal Institute is the first bulwark
in Congress for the appraisal industry.
Our national office is on top of all legislation impacting appraisers
and making sure appraiser concerns are heard.
At the state level the Chapter is a voice that is heard on regulatory
issues both in the legislature and at the administrative level.
Barrie Gaman, MAI is the President of the Massachusetts Chapter of the Appraisal Institute and is a Vice President/Market Manager for Commercial Appraisal Services at Bank of America in Waltham, MA.